An engagement is inside IR35 if, for tax purposes, you would be an employee of the client if you supplied the services directly. The assessment looks at the contract and how the work is carried out in practice. Assess each engagement separately, including who is responsible for making the decision.
IR35 can be difficult because the consequences affect the contractor, the client and often an agency in the chain. The right starting point is to gather the facts, understand who is responsible for making the status decision and keep evidence that reflects how the engagement actually works.
What does inside or outside IR35 mean?
IR35 is the commonly used name for the off-payroll working rules. They are intended to make sure that a worker who provides services through an intermediary, usually their own limited company, pays broadly the Income Tax and National Insurance that an employee would pay where the underlying relationship is one of employment.
HMRC explains that the rules apply where the worker would have been an employee if they had provided their services directly to the client. Read the current official IR35 guidance for the legal framework and current responsibilities.
| Status outcome | What it broadly means | Practical consequence |
|---|---|---|
| Outside IR35 | The engagement is a genuine business-to-business arrangement on the facts. | The contractor’s company remains responsible for its usual tax and accounting obligations. |
| Inside IR35 | The engagement is treated as employment for tax purposes. | Who accounts for PAYE and National Insurance depends on the client and which IR35 rules apply. |
“Inside” and “outside” are tax status outcomes for an engagement. They do not necessarily change the quality of your work, your professional identity or the commercial value you bring to a client.
Who decides the IR35 status?
This is one of the first questions to answer. Responsibility depends largely on the client and the circumstances of the engagement.
- Public-sector clients. The client normally has responsibility for determining employment status for tax purposes.
- Medium and large private-sector clients. The client normally makes the determination and should provide a status determination statement (SDS) with reasons.
- Small private-sector clients. The contractor’s intermediary is normally responsible for deciding whether the rules apply.
- Agencies in the chain. Agencies can have responsibilities, particularly when they are the party treated as the deemed employer.
Ask the client to confirm its size in writing if you are unsure. For companies with a standard 12-month financial year, the higher company-size thresholds can first affect IR35 from 2027/28. When the new tests apply, the thresholds are £15 million turnover, £7.5 million balance sheet total and 50 employees. A company generally needs to exceed at least two to count as medium or large. The relevant financial years and, where applicable, group figures affect the decision. HMRC’s guidance on the IR35 client-size changes.
What factors determine IR35 status?
There is no single magic question. A written contract matters, but the day-to-day reality matters too. The status analysis looks at the whole relationship.
| Area | Questions to ask | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Control | Who decides what work is done, when it is done, where it is done and how it is delivered? | Employee-like control can point towards employment, although professional contractors may naturally have some client direction. |
| Personal service and substitution | Must you personally provide the services, or is there a genuine and workable right to send a suitably qualified substitute? | A real substitution arrangement can be relevant, but a clause that is never practical may carry little weight. |
| Financial risk | Do you quote for a project, correct defects at your own cost, carry insurance or risk making a loss? | Genuine business risk can support a business-to-business relationship. |
| Integration | Are you part of the client’s organisation in the same way as staff, or an independent supplier with a defined service? | Being fully integrated can point towards employment, though access and collaboration alone are not decisive. |
| Mutual obligations | For this engagement, are you obliged to do the work and is the client obliged to pay for it? | A single accepted assignment can meet this part of the employment test. Look at the rest of the working arrangement to decide status. |
The Supreme Court explained in HMRC v Professional Game Match Officials Ltd that the obligations to do work and pay for it can exist for each accepted engagement, even where there is no commitment to offer or accept future work. A series of separately agreed projects can still include engagements that are inside IR35.
These factors must be assessed together. A contractor can work mostly from a client site and still be outside IR35, just as a contractor with a substitution clause can be inside if the reality is employee-like. The facts and the evidence matter more than a label.
Contract wording and working practices must match
A well-drafted contract is useful, but it cannot fix a different day-to-day reality. If the contract says you control how work is delivered but a manager directs every task, working hour and holiday arrangement, the actual working practices may undermine the written terms.
Before accepting an engagement, read the contract alongside the client’s expectations. Then document the arrangement as it operates. Keep project scopes, statements of work, emails that show agreed deliverables, invoices, evidence of equipment or insurance, and any correspondence about substitution or independence.
If the engagement changes, revisit the assessment. A new role, extension, manager, location or method of working can change the relevant facts. IR35 is not a once-and-for-all label for your company.
Use CEST carefully
HMRC’s Check Employment Status for Tax tool, commonly called CEST, can help gather and assess the relevant facts. It can be used by clients, agencies and workers. HMRC states that it will stand by the result where the information entered remains accurate and follows its guidance.
That means the quality of the input matters. Do not rush through the questions from memory or use an answer that makes the outcome look attractive. Collect the contract, statement of work and an honest description of the working arrangement first. You can access the CEST guidance and tool through GOV.UK.
Build an evidence pack while the engagement is live
IR35 evidence is stronger when it is created as the work happens. Keep the signed contract, statement of work, status determination, any CEST output, scope changes, invoices and correspondence about delivery. If the engagement is project-based, retain evidence of agreed milestones, acceptance of work and the way you managed the service independently.
This is not about manufacturing a story after the event. It is about retaining the normal commercial records that show how the business relationship genuinely operated. If HMRC or a client asks a question later, a clear record is far more persuasive than a recollection months after the project ended.
What happens when an engagement is inside IR35?
Where the off-payroll rules apply and the client is responsible for the determination, the deemed employer normally deducts Income Tax and employee National Insurance from the fee paid to the contractor’s intermediary. Employer National Insurance and, where applicable, Apprenticeship Levy obligations also need to be considered by the deemed employer.
If the client is a small private-sector organisation and the rules apply, your intermediary is generally responsible for working out and accounting for any deemed employment payment. HMRC’s IR35 guidance for contractors working with small clients.
The contractor’s company still exists and still needs proper accounts and records. But the way income reaches the company, the deductions made and the company’s tax position may be different from an outside-IR35 contract. Do not assume that all income from an inside-IR35 engagement can be treated as ordinary company profit available for dividends.
How do you challenge an IR35 status determination?
For engagements where the client is responsible for the assessment, the client should issue a status determination statement, usually called an SDS. It should state the conclusion and the reasons for it. A simple “inside IR35” label with no factual explanation is not a useful basis for a commercial conversation or a robust record.
If you disagree with an SDS, write to the client and explain which contract terms or working practices it has misunderstood. The client generally has 45 calendar days to respond, either by giving reasons for keeping the original decision or by issuing a new SDS. Keep the correspondence with your contract records. HMRC’s client-led disagreement guidance.
Clients should have a consistent process too. Gather information from the hiring manager and the contractor, use a documented assessment method and avoid blanket decisions based only on job role. Roles with the same title can operate very differently in practice.
Tax status is not the same as employment rights
IR35 concerns employment status for tax purposes. It does not by itself decide employment-law rights such as holiday pay, notice or unfair-dismissal rights. Those questions use related but different legal tests. Do not rely on an IR35 assessment as a complete answer to every employment-status question.
That distinction matters for both contractors and clients. Complex engagements may need specialist legal advice as well as accounting and tax support, particularly where contracts, worker rights or a status dispute are involved.
Practical steps for contractors
- Ask early. Find out who the client is, whether an agency is involved and who will make the status decision.
- Read the contract. Check that the wording describes the service you will actually provide, not a generic employment-style role.
- Review the reality. Consider control, substitution, risk, integration and the wider relationship honestly.
- Keep evidence. Save the contract, SDS, CEST result if used, scopes of work, correspondence and invoices.
- Challenge promptly. If you disagree with an SDS, use the client-led disagreement process and explain the factual basis for your view.
- Revisit changes. Treat a material change in the engagement as a reason to reassess, not an inconvenience to ignore.
Practical steps for small-business clients
If you hire contractors through their own companies, do not ignore the question. Clarify whether your business meets the small-client conditions, who is contracting with whom and what service you are buying. Where you are responsible for an assessment, use a fair, documented process rather than relying on the contractor’s preferred outcome.
Good onboarding helps. Your contracts, project scope, reporting arrangements and invoicing should reflect a genuine supplier relationship if that is what you intend. Avoid treating an external contractor exactly like an employee while expecting a different tax result.
IR35 is not just a tax-box exercise
A sound IR35 process also protects commercial relationships. Clear scopes, agreed deliverables, sensible payment terms and written responsibilities help both parties understand the engagement. They can also make the contractor’s business easier to manage, quote and insure.
For contractors operating through companies, reliable bookkeeping and a clear distinction between company and personal money remain essential. Our guides to Xero cloud accounting for small businesses, capital allowances and preparing your first Corporation Tax bill explain the accounting foundations around the status decision.
Get a clear view of your contracting position
SB Business Consulting provides practical accounting and tax support for contractors, consultants and small businesses in Cheltenham, throughout Gloucestershire and nationwide. I can help you understand the accounting implications of your engagements and keep your company records in order, while legal employment-status advice may also be appropriate for complex cases. Explore our limited company accounts service and business advice and tax planning service.
Last reviewed 13 November 2026. This article is general information, not legal or employment-status advice. IR35 outcomes are highly fact-specific, and rules can change. Review each engagement on its own facts and obtain tailored advice where needed.

Leave a Reply